Your worth is purely based on your age.
April 30th, 2007 by Kyle
There it is,
There is my biggest problem with labor unions.
“Pinski said the company wants to exempt less-experienced workers from layoffs if they have skills deemed essential to production. The machinists want layoffs based strictly on seniority.”
Is there is any universe it which that is good policy?
When the next inevitable downturn in aviation comes, the union wants to lay off the young skilled workers so that crotchety old guys can keep earning their $40/hour jobs, defined pension, and full-health coverage. I believe we can file this one under “mortgaging our future and blowing the money on Viagra.”
Pop quiz, what do the following have in common?
Rodents
Lions
Labor Unions
Answer: They all eat their young.
Wouldn’t the viable alternative be to evaluate all workers based on their skill and productivity, then if you have to downsize, layoff the workers from the bottom up? It would increase productivity by getting rid of dead weight and ensure the company a quicker ascent and return to profitability. It would also mean, on average, that less people would lose their jobs.
How can anybody be against that? How can any union be against saving their members’ jobs?
Maybe this is the reason union membership has been dropping for a decade. You can blame it on outsourcing, but the real reason is that the younger workers are abandoning unions, because their unions sell them out.
I work with many younger workers who could be represented by the IAM, and I hear the same story again and again. It usually goes something like this, “I joined the union when I first started this job, went to a couple of meetings, read their bargaining agreement and realized that I would lose my job in any layoff because I’m new. The 55-year-old working next to me wouldn’t, simply because he’s been here for 25 years. I’m better and faster at my job, and he makes 3-times as much money. I wasn’t going to pay dues to save that jerk’s job, so I quit the union.”
I’ve heard at least four different variations on that story. It’s not a unique nor irrational sentiment to not want to be sold out. To have it done by your “defenders” is especially heinous. Until the sentiment changes, the preservation of mediocrity will always be my biggest problem with unions.
Category: Reality Cheque | 1 Comment »